Lawsuit filed over ‘Kerrygold’ Irish butter ban in Wisconsin

BUTTER BAN UNCONSTITUTIONAL, W.I.L.L. SAYS

Posted at 11:15 a.m. on March 17, 2017

The Brillion News

PORT WASHINGTON –  On behalf of four consumers and Slow Pokes Local Foods, the Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty (WILL) has filed a lawsuit against the State of Wisconsin to preserve the freedom to buy and sell whatever type of butter one wishes to.

Wisconsin’s current protectionist law prohibits the sale of any butter that hasn’t been labeled by government taste testers.  This archaic labeling regime prevents Wisconsin residents from enjoying very popular butters such as Kerrygold, a high-quality Irish import made by Ornua, the owner of the former Thiel Cheese plant in St. John.

Violators risk jail time or thousands of dollars in fines.  Wisconsin is the only state in the country with specific and onerous labeling requirements that prevent the sale of Kerrygold and other similarly produced butters.

According to WILL President Rick Esenberg: “Because the Wisconsin butter law serves no adequate government purpose, it is one of those laws that violate the due process and equal protection guarantees of the Wisconsin Constitution.  The requirement that sellers of butter engage in compelled speech – that they publicize the government’s opinion of how a butter tastes – also violates the guarantee of free speech.”

“Wisconsin is well known as the ‘dairy state’, so it is ironic that Wisconsin consumers and businesses don’t have a full range of butter options like every other state in the union,” added Associate Counsel Jake Curtis.  “The protectionist labeling requirements of the butter law in no way relate to health or safety concerns and therefore the state of Wisconsin has no rational basis for impeding the economic freedom of Wisconsin consumers and businesses. We have all the confidence in the world that Wisconsin’s butter producers can compete with the likes of Kerrygold.  But in order for the state of Wisconsin to continue its upward climb, we cannot remain in the business of erecting, or in this case preserving, artificial barriers to product entry.”

Kerrygold is a brand of Ornua, the Irish Dairy Board cooperative, which purchased Thiel Cheese in St. John, in the Town of Woodville in northern Calumet County, and expanded the plant into a state-of-the-art dairy products manufacturing facility.

A 1953 Wisconsin law requires all butter sold in the State be sampled by government-licensed “butter tasters.”  Once tasted, butter is issued a grade and then labeled during the packaging process.  Wisconsin is the only state in the union to impose such a labeling requirement.  Those who sell butter in Wisconsin without the proper label face up to one year in a county jail, up to $5,000 in fines, and a permanent injunction against future butter sales.

As highlighted by recent media accounts, the butter law has prevented Wisconsin grocery stores from legally selling certain brands of butter.  One example is the incredibly popular Kerrygold butter, made in Ireland. Kerrygold claims to produce the “sweetest, richest milk in the world, which makes our grass-fed cow’s milk Irish butter taste silky and creamy and glow a healthy, golden yellow.”

WILL said its clients, who in some cases have been able to get their hands on the creamy contraband by traveling to other states, wish to have the freedom to enjoy the butter of their choice without risking time in their local county jail, thousands of dollars in fines, and a permanent injunction against selling the butter.

WILL said protectionist measures such as the Wisconsin butter labeling requirements are inconsistent with the competitive federalism championed by WILL’s Center for Competitive Federalism.  States are certainly free to set their own polices.  However, as courts have long held, a state may not protect favored interests from the impact of those policies without a clearly defined rational basis.  Wisconsin has no such basis in this case, WILL believes.

WILL President Rick Esenberg and Attorneys Jake Curtis and Clyde Taylor filed the lawsuit in Ozaukee County Circuit Court.